Activity 1: Warm-up · 5 minutes
Spot the Error
a) Aims
Ss recall the form of non-defining relative clauses and identify the common mistakes of omitting commas, using 'that' and dropping the relative pronoun.
b) Content
Ss look at three faulty sentences on the board and decide what is wrong:
- This wetland that stores floodwater needs protection.
- Ms Ha, that works at the centre, gave a talk.
- The Earth, which it is our home, needs care.
Ss then say how to correct each sentence.
c) Expected outcomes
Ss identify three errors and give corrected sentences:
- 1: This wetland, which stores floodwater, needs protection. (missing commas; 'that' is not used in a non-defining clause)
- 2: Ms Ha, who works at the centre, gave a talk. (a named person takes 'who', not 'that')
- 3: The Earth, which is our home, needs care. (the repeated subject 'it' must be removed)
d) Organisation
Teacher's activities
Students' activities
Teacher
Step 1: Task delivering
T writes the three sentences on the board and says: 'Look at these sentences. Something is wrong in each one. Can you find the mistakes?' T gives 1 minute.
Students
Ss read the sentences silently and think about what is wrong.
Teacher
Step 2: Task performance
T walks around and listens. T prompts with 'What is the subject? Do we need commas here?' if Ss are stuck.
Students
Ss work individually, then whisper their answers to a neighbour. Typical answer: 'There are no commas.' / 'We should use who for a person.'
Teacher
Step 3: Report and discussion
T calls on individual Ss to give a corrected version of each sentence and asks the class: 'Do you agree?'
Students
Ss read out the corrected sentences. Other Ss agree or suggest a change.
Teacher
Step 4: Conclusion and assessment
T confirms the three corrected sentences and writes on the board: 'Non-defining clause = extra information + commas + who/which/whose, never that, never omit the pronoun.' T links this to the lesson title Looking Back.
Students
Ss copy the key point into their notebooks.